Belonging: A Journey of Love book review

Belonging: A Journey of Love – Book Review

Author: Sonia Gandhi

Publisher: HarperCollins India

Released: 10 November 2026

Genre: Memoir

Length: 544 pages

What does it actually mean to belong to a country that was once outside her experience, and how does one gradually make it into a home ? I found this question at the heart of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir; Belonging: A Journey of Love, a memoir that beautifully imprints her journey from a small Italian town to the center of one of India’s most prominent political families. Born Edvige Antonia Albina Maino, commonly known as Antonia Maino or Sonia Maino, in post-war Italy, she grew up in a middle-class family before meeting Rajiv Gandhi in Cambridge in 1965. One of the moments that stood out to me was her description of their first encounter, she vibrantly describes it as un colpo di fulmine:  a bolt of lightning. Then comes her account of their courtship, marriage in February 1968 and her subsequent move to India which critically marks the beginning of a life shaped by a new language, culture, family and,ultimately, politics. I find the title particularly meaningful because the sense of belonging here is not merely about geographical resettlement. It is also about building a sense of self through relationships, experiences, choices and time. I found the account of her Italian childhood particularly interesting because it forms  a part of her life which has often been overlooked in the sphere of public discussions. Her familiarization to India becomes easier to understand when viewed through the family values and social environment in which she grew up.

The book unfolds seamlessly through seven parts;  Love and Courtship, Finding My Way, Triumphs and Defeats, Rajiv as Prime Minister, Dénouement and Aftermath, Leading the Congress Party and Twenty Years On. Its personal photographs, including family moments and pictures of Rajiv and Sonia, add another important dimension to the narrative, making it feel at times like a compilation of cherished memories. One of the most insightful aspects for me is  her candid recollections of the Nehru-Gandhi household, her relationship with Indira Gandhi and the everyday tensions within the family. The lighter recollections of the cramped living arrangements after the Congress lost the 1977 election sit alongside the traumatic experiences. Sonia Gandhi  recounts the loss of her first child, Sanjay Gandhi’s death, Indira Gandhi’s assassination and, eventually, Rajiv Gandhi’s assassination. Her account of pleading with Rajiv not to become Prime Minister after his mother’s distressing death is emotionally resonant when read against his assassination seven years later.

I was particularly interested in her initial reluctance to enter politics, the attacks she faced and her decision to decline the Prime Minister’s position in 2004 . She explains why she proposed Manmohan Singh for the post, outlining him as a person of integrity and administrative experience. She also addresses the accusations about her influence over his government, upholding that Singh headed the government while she led the Congress.

However, I found the  memoir more intricate when personal memories of the past intertwine with communal political history. The Emergency, the 1984 anti-Sikh violence, the Babri Masjid demolition and the Bofors controversy are not merely family experiences; they are events that continue to shape India’s public memory. Her portrayal of the Emergency places considerable emphasis on Sanjay Gandhi’s influence. While reading her account of the 1984 violence, I felt that the question of the political responsibility of Congress leaders deserved greater attention.  I also found the limited discussion of Ottavio Quattrocchi in the Bofors chapter worth questioning. I was also left with questions about the memoir’s portrayal of her father, Stefano Maino. I believe this affectionate portrayal of her father needs to be considered alongside the wider history of Fascist Italy and its military involvement during the Second World War. These are the queries that deserve evaluation without holding a daughter responsible for her father’s actions.

I also noticed some  factual discrepancies that cannot be simply overlooked. Reports have underscored, among other examples, the incorrect year given for the RSS’s foundation, Ahmed Patel’s death and the emergence of the Anna Hazare movement. Such errors raise legitimate questions about historical accuracy and editorial scrutiny. Yet the memoir’s value lies in the disparity it portrays . On one side is a woman who left her birthplace, entered an unexplored country and endured profound personal losses. On the other is a political figure whose family’s history is inseparable from the making of modern India. She is entitled to narrate her private life from her own perspective; a memoir need not read like a neutral history textbook. But when personal memory enters the territory of collective history, readers are equally entitled to ask what has been included, what has been excluded and how events have been interpreted.

Ultimately, Belonging: A Journey of Love is most persuasive when it allows readers to encounter the person behind the public figure. Its silences and historical inaccuracies, however, limit its value as a complete political account. The book also arrives at a moment when public interest in reading and addressing books seems to be finding fresh momentum. Perhaps its greatest contribution is the gesture to look beyond the familiar political image and contemplate the personal journey behind it; while commemorating that belonging to a family and belonging to a nation’s history are not always the same thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *