Chanda Kochhar’s husband Deepak Kochhar has been arrested under ICICI bank and Videocon loan case by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in an alleged money laundering case against the loan transactions of ICICI Bank and the Videocon group.
According to the Enforcement Directorate, Deepak Kochhar was arrested due to his lack of cooperation in the investigation. Mr Kochhar is due for a hearing in an anti-money laundering court in Delhi today.
The initially blown whistles; speculations and notices
Speculation regarding the breach of the code of conduct between ICICI bank and the Videocon group surfaced in 2016, when Arvind Gupta, a shareholder of both ICICI Bank and Videocon Group, published a blog raising concerns about the practices taking place in both companies.
In 2016, Arvind Gupta alleged that Chanda Kochhar, the former managing director and chief executive officer of ICICI Bank, regulated a loan of Rs 3,250-crore to the Videocon group in 2012. He also alleged that the loan was given out in the exchange of a deal with a clean-energy firm run by her husband Deepak Kochhar called NuPower Renewables along with Supreme Energy.
Two years later, an anonymous person alleged an intentional delay between the years 2008 and 2016 in recognising damage to 31 loan accounts to reduce the bank’s provisioning costs, by the ICICI bank and its management, including Chanda Kochhar.
This time, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) and Enforcement Directorate (ED) responded to the allegations and launched an inquiry into the matter. The CBI also launched a private inquiry and interrogated Chanda Kochhar’s husband, Deepak Kochhar, and brother Rajeev Kochhar about the allegations.
ICICI Bank chairman, MK Sharma, responded to the claims, expressing full faith in Chanda Kochhar and issued a statement calling the allegations “robust” after an internal inquiry into the matter. ICICI Bank pointed out that even though Chanda Kochhar was present on the committee that approved the loan, she did not have any personal take on the matter.
In a press meeting, MK Sharma told the press that, “The board has come to the conclusion that there is no question of any quid pro quo/ nepotism/ conflict of interest as is being alleged in various rumors,” He further added that, “ICICI Bank was not the lead bank for this consortium and the bank only sanctioned its share of facilities aggregating approximately Rs 3,250 crore which was less than 10 percent of the total consortium facility in April 2012”.
M.K Sharma added, “It can be concluded that there are adequate checks and balances in loan appraisal, rating and approval processes within the bank, both from a control as well as from a governance perspective.”
ICICI Bank later issued another statement denying NuPower and ICICI Bank links as none of the company’s investors borrowed any money from the bank.
Investigations and resignations
After the banks issued a statement in support of Chanda Kochhar and claims of the rightful passage of loans to the Venugopal Dhoot led Videocon, the SFIO took permission from the Ministry of Corporate Affairs to start an investigation into the 2012 loan deal.
On 23rd May 2018, The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) sent a notice to Chanda Kochhar to provide all the information regarding the Videocon Group loan dealings and also to the NuPower Renewables for the acquirement of all the lender dealings of the entity.
The SEBI market regulator served a 12-page show-cause notice to Chanda Kochhar and the ICICI bank with a submission deadline on 7th June 2018.
As the investigation was put in place, the ICICI bank launched its own independent internal investigation into the matter. The ICICI bank invited a retired Judge of the Supreme Court of India, Justice BN Srikrishna, to head the investigation.
During the ongoing internal investigation, Chanda Kochhar and the ICICI bank failed to respond to the show-cause notice until the deadline, due to the lack of documentation proof.
SEBI extended Kochhar’s deadline until 10th July 2018.
During the investigation, Chanda Kochhar applied for an early retirement, which was accepted by the ICICI bank board. The bank later assured that it would not affect the internal investigation in any way, and whatever the outcome may be, action would be taken accordingly.
The final verdict of the internal committee looking into the matter, headed by Justice BN Srikrishna, reported that Chanda Kochhar did violate the bank’s code of conduct in the Videocon loan case. The bank then concluded that it would view Kochhar’s separation from the company as “termination for cause,” according to internal policies.
CBI files FIR against Venugopal Dhoot and Deepak Kochhar
In January 2019, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) filed a First Information Report (FIR) against Venugopal Dhoot, the chairman of the Videocon group, and Deepak Kochhar, Chanda Kochhar’s husband. The FIR was filed out of concern for the Rs. 3,250 crore loan agreement between ICICI Bank and Videocon Group.
The CBI alleged that Venugopal Dhoot invested the entire loaned amount in NuPower Renewables and Supreme Energy, a firm owned by Deepak Kochhar, just a couple months after its approval.
Raids were conducted by the CBI in the Mumbai offices and homes of Venugopal Dhoot, Deepak Kochhar, and Chanda Kochhar. The CBI revealed that during the two-year term, from June 2009 to October 2011, six high-value loans were permitted from ICICI Bank to the Videocon Group. This was a short while after Chanda Kochhar took over the position of the Managing Director (MD) of the ICICI Bank in May 2009.
Companies NuPower Renewables (NRL) and Supreme Energy Private Limited (SEPL) were also booked in for the investigation. The SEPL was initially owned by Venugopal Dhoot, who became a 94.99% shareholder of NRL within a year. Later, the shares were sold to Deepak Kochhar and eventually from him and his relatives to SEPL. Eight months later, Dhoot transferred all his remaining shares to the company where Deepak Kochhar was a trustee.
RBI steps in and files a report
A report submitted by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) stated that RBI was informed about over Rs. 320 crores in five tranches of the NRL, the company owned by Deepak Kochhar.
It also stated that RBI was unsuccessful in tracking the origin of funds raised by the company between march 2011 and march 2012.
ICICI Bank recovery suit against Chanda Kochhar.
After Chanda Kochhar’s resignation from the post of MD and CEO from the bank was turned into a ‘termination for cause’ by the bank, Chanda Kochhar filed a suit against the bank in the Bombay High Court. Her suit was based on ICICI terminating her employment after accepting her request for early retirement.
During the court hearing of the suit filed by Kochhar, her lawyer came to know about the counter-suit filed by ICICI Bank. According to the bank, since ICICI is a private bank and is headed by a board of directors, Ms Kochher’s suit was not maintainable.
ICICI Bank also submitted a 28-page response, stating that Kochhar’s termination was a result of a lack of disclosure.
ICICI Bank’s recovery suit against the former MD and CEO of the bank, Chanda Kochhar, seeks recovery of around Rs. 12 crores that Ms Kochhar received as part of the bonus and other benefits before her termination. According to the bank, the bonus was imbursed between April 2006 and March 2018.
2020 and final decisions regarding the case
In January of this year, the ED attached a recovery of assets worth more than Rs. 78 crore in the possession of Chanda Kochhar and her family. Some of the assets that were recovered by the ED included her Mumbai residence.
Three months later, the Bombay High Court dismissed Ms. Kochhar’s case against the ICICI Bank, stating that Ms. Kochhar was terminated after her voluntary resignation.
During the same time, CBI booked Venugopal Dhoot, the former chairman of the Videocon Group, for cheating multiple banks of millions of rupees.
On Monday, September 7, came the arrest of Deepak Kochhar by the ED after questioning him for the last time. The agency states that it has found enough evidence against Deepak Kochhar to put the arrest in place.
The investigation into the Kochhar family and Venugopal Dhoot in the money laundering case is still going on, conducted by the income tax department, CBI, ED, and SFIO.
Why Olaf Scholz, Chancellor of Germany, is sending a message of Independence by visiting China
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz was the first G7 head of state to visit China since the outbreak. After the public health crisis, the world changed. The relationship between China and Germany seems to be returning to normal. Since Xi Jinping was re-crowned as the General Secretary of the Communist Party of China, Scholz is the first prominent European figure to visit China.
Nguyen PhuTrong, the head of the Vietnamese Communist Party, Shehbaz Sharif, and Samia Hassan, the president of Tanzania, arrived in Beijing before Scholz. Given that China’s relations with Europe have deteriorated due to Uyghur human rights in Xinjiang and Chinese support for Russia in the Ukraine conflict, the Scholz visit last week was positive for Beijing.
Germany’s biggest European economy will be even more reliant on China in the first quarter of 2022. During this time, Germany invested €10 billion in China. The amount of bilateral commerce increased by 0.9% to $173.57 billion. Imports from Germany are up 54%. The medium-term ambitions of Germany are in jeopardy due to its 1.9% growth rate.
German investment in China grew by 30% in 2022 despite the Ukraine crisis and criticism of China. A €69.5 billion railway project connecting Tianjin, in North China, and Beijing Daxing International Airport is being financed by KfW (the German state-owned development and investment bank), BASF, Hella, and Robert Bosch. For a total of $17 billion, China is purchasing 140 Airbus planes. Costco, a Chinese shipping business, was permitted to invest in Germany’s busiest port, Hamburg, prior to the visit, but with a smaller share. Additionally, the arrival of Scholz coincided with polarization and deteriorating US-China ties. Due to the Ukraine conflict, Germany soon adopted a similar strategy to the US, breaking its contact with Russia.
It maintains caution regarding China because its economic interests are crucial. Scholz met with PM Modi in Berlin after starting his Asia strategy with a visit to Japan rather than China. Germany’s foreign policy did not give China top priority, but it is nevertheless significant. It looks inconvenient that the visit comes right after the CCP’s 20th National Congress.
Germany confronting China alone has angered Europe. Germany rejected the joint Scholz-Macron visit. The visit by Scholz and a corporate delegation demonstrates a duplication of Angela Merkel’s approach. German businesses, which are already suffering from the epidemic, the energy crisis, and the break from Russia, according to the ruling SPD, cannot afford to decouple from China. The German Foreign Ministry criticizes China’s human rights record and is developing a new China strategy to counter the systemic rivalry that the EU anticipated.
The Scholz visit revealed strategic independence in Germany. When viewed from the perspective of German relations with Russia, the same autonomy is apparent.
If Germany sways away for its own reasons, how will it continue to lead Europe? Scholz needed to pull many savvy rabbits out of his Beijing visit if he wanted to position Germany and potentially Europe as independent players in the inevitable US-China polarization.
Scholz provided background information for his visit in an opinion piece that was published in the FAZ the day before. Since Merkel’s most recent trip to China in 2019, he admitted that the world had undergone significant upheaval. It was crucial to have a face-to-face meeting with Xi in order to address the world’s unresolved problems, not because he intended to carry on as normal. China had seen a major upheaval. The German approach had to adapt as well because China had changed.
Additionally, the world had changed. Russia posed a menace that needed Chinese assistance to counter. China was reminded of its unique duty to uphold the UN Charter’s ideals and exert influence over Russia as a permanent member of the UN Security Council. This is similar to what China claims about Russia in its Global Security Initiative, which it has yet to put into action. Scholz talked about the necessity of increasing Germany’s partnerships and the multipolarity of the world.
Berlin works with various partners because he does not want to see blocs reemerge. China shouldn’t be left alone, and a Chinese-dominated world system cannot be cozy. Germany and Europe continue to value China as a trading partner. Berlin didn’t want to cut its ties with it. With China, Germany would want more parity and economic diversification. When it came to rare earth, cutting-edge technologies, or raw resources, “risky dependencies” had grown. German enterprises were developing different supply chains. China and Germany will now look for a differentiated basis for trade and investment. Instead of “protectionism and withdrawal,” Germany prefers diversity and strengthening.
Scholz’s fourth goal was that the disparities between China and Germany, notably those involving political and civil rights, including in Xinjiang, could not be overlooked. Scholz stated that while Germany adheres to the One-China policy, any change to Taiwan’s status must be peaceful and reached via mutual consent.
Germany’s China policy, according to Scholz, will be effective if it is in line with European policy. In his opinion, there were various areas where China should have a role, including dealing with the G 20, the SDGs, and other things. Before his visit, he consulted with the EU, French President Macron, and the US.
The Chinese readout supports the majority of what Scholz claimed. To preserve Germany’s strategic autonomy, Xi is courting it. Despite Scholz’s concerns, it stated that “there should be no self-imposed constraints or unrealistic expectations” and publicly disregarded the Taiwan and Xinjiang issues.
This visit is significant because Germany has again demonstrated its desire for strategic independence from the US. Before the Ukraine crisis, which caused them all to flee in the wake of NATO and US leadership, the German coalition and other German and European nations had this as their top priority. Europe is suffering from sanctions and a diminished energy supply due to the standoff in the Ukraine conflict. Despite resistance from within Germany and outside Europe, Germany appears prepared to continue its relationship with China. It must protect its economic growth against the ravages of conflict.
Elections in Nepal Are Crucial For India As Xi Jinping is Growing Interest in South Asia
In a recent essay published in The Kathmandu Post, China’s departing ambassador to Nepal, HouYanqi, mentioned the forthcoming parliamentary elections and expressed the hope that bilateral relations will “continue to achieve new levels.”
It was clear from Beijing’s overt indication that it wanted to maintain strong bilateral relations irrespective of the outcome. Since China has a lot riding on the election results on November 20, India, Nepal’s other prominent neighbor, agrees.
The influence of Nepal, which is geographically positioned between the two Asian superpowers, has been the subject of a high-stakes power struggle between them. They both want a “friendly” administration in Kathmandu in a few weeks.
However, Nepal’s elections are just some of the ones being watched closely by China and India. The US is similarly interested in the outcome, given its fierce regional competition with China.
The US spent significant diplomatic capital over the past year to ensure Kathmandu agreed to its own $500 million Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) agreement that calls for constructing roads and energy infrastructure in Nepal. This was done to counter China’s multi-billion dollar Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) in the Indo-Pacific, which Nepal has endorsed.
Though on the surface, Washington’s State Partnership Programme (SPP) appeared to entail the Nepal Army collaborating with the Utah State National Guard on “humanitarian and disaster management” issues, Kathmandu has been unable to join. However, the SPP has a hidden military purpose and the goal of bringing Nepal on board with the American Indo-Pacific strategy.
Once elections for the 275-member House of Representatives (PratinidhiSabha) and its seven provincial assemblies are complete, New Delhi, Beijing, and Washington will all seek a government in Kathmandu that will protect, if not advance, their strategic interests.
Two erratic electoral coalitions have been established for the time being, with the same old, senile warhorses vying for the position of prime minister. Current Nepali Congress leader SherBahadurDeuba leads one alliance, while former PM K P Sharma Oli of the Communist Party of Nepal-Unified Marxist Leninist leads the other.
Given that Nepalese leaders are motivated more by political expediency and opportunism than by ideology, it is not surprising that Pushpa Kamal Dahal, the leader of the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist Centre), who was formerly a member of the grand Communist alliance, is now a member of the coalition led by Deuba.
Also Read: A Cruel Birth of Bangladesh – Book Review
Madhav Kumar Nepal, another former prime minister, is also a member of the ruling coalition. After criticizing Oli’s authoritarian behavior, he broke up his relationship with him last year, dividing the CPN-UML. He is presently the leader of Nepal’s newly established Communist Party (Unified Socialist).
A stable Nepali administration that prioritizes its strategic interests is essential for India. However, stability is unlikely to even in the following administration, given the infamy. Nepalese politicians have amassed due to their unquenchable quest for power and the prime ministership.
In addition to causing severe political turmoil within Nepal to ensure his government’s survival, pro-China Oli’s tenure as prime minister caused New Delhi some difficulty. He ferociously incited nationalist feelings, even changing Nepal’s map, sparking a response to the Kalapani territorial dispute with India. As a result, under his leadership, relations between New Delhi and Kathmandu were considerably chilly.
Following Deuba’s appointment as PM in July of last year, who was seen as being pro-India, there was a thaw. Although a coalition administration would make his position shaky as well, New Delhi would likely gamble on Deuba returning to lead the government.
India, which historically regarded Nepal as its backyard because of its connections to civilization and culture and its physical proximity, has seen its influence there fade even as China has made significant gains, luring the nation with its resources and building projects.
Even more, concerning for India is the fact that Beijing has established strong bonds not just with the Communist parties but also with Nepalese leaders who cross party lines. Therefore, the outcome of the election is much more vital for New Delhi.
The fact that the outgoing Chinese envoy publicly attempted to serve as a “peace-maker” to keep the feuding factions of the ruling Nepal Communist Party (NCP) united when Oli was prime minister two years ago provides evidence of the extent to which Chinese influence has permeated Nepal’s political system.
Beijing exerted much effort to bring the Communist parties—the Oli-led CPN-UML and the Dahal-led CPN (Maoist Centre)—together. India is well aware that China will continue its efforts to make sure the Communist-led coalition wins, even though this front collapsed due to the fierce struggle for dominance between Oli and Dahal. New Delhi will be crossing its fingers in the hopes that the new political climate in Kathmandu will be stable and advantageous.
How Does Poverty Impact Education of Children?
One of the main areas where family incomes have an impact is educational outcomes. As seen by school readiness assessments, children from low-income homes frequently begin school behind their counterparts from more affluent families. Along with neighborhood factors and social networks, poverty’s occurrence, depth, duration, and timeliness impact a child’s educational success. However, interventions conducted in Canada and abroad have demonstrated that the impacts of poverty can be diminished by employing long-lasting solutions. In primary care settings, pediatricians and family physicians have numerous possibilities to influence student’s preparation for school and academic achievement. In addition to food, shelter, and clothing, education is one of the necessities of modern existence.
The Indian Constitution has given everyone the right to live honorably and with dignity toward all citizens. The State has been taking several actions to guarantee this fundamental right. The universalization of free and obligatory primary education for all children of school age is one of them—additionally, the right to adhere to and spread faith and religion. In contrast, formal education is a means of guaranteeing the right to live with honor and dignity. In a multireligious secular nation like ours, the latter is a prerequisite environment—to practice and spread the faith of one’s own free will.
Impact of Childhood Poverty on Student’s Education and Their Life Trajectory
Education is a potent weapon for combating poverty and unemployment, enhancing nutritional and health standards, and reaching environmental protection. The formal education system recognizes primary education as a fundamental human right and essential for each person’s personal and social growth. A catalyst is provided by education. It causes changes in society’s economy, culture, and technology. It is said to be the most crucial method of improving one’s characteristics, overcoming obstacles, and seizing further possibilities for long-lasting well-being enhancement. Many individuals are impacted by poverty. But it might be argued that kids are most affected by poverty. And with 1.21 billion people on the planet, children in India who live below the poverty line will undoubtedly suffer the consequences.
Poverty not only hinders a child’s growth but also negatively impacts a child’s educational performance and a lack of access to moral guidance and a moral framework. In the earliest years of life, poverty affects a child’s development and educational outcomes directly and indirectly through mediated, regulated, and transactional processes. In the United States and increasingly developing nations, it has been acknowledged that school readiness, or a child’s capacity to use and benefit from education, plays a unique role in helping people transcend poverty. Although it is a crucial component, a strategy to reduce poverty must include numerous other elements, such as better opportunity frameworks and family empowerment.
How Does Poverty Impact Education of Children in India
India, which now has the world’s third-largest purchasing power parity economy, has been an urban-cantered, industrializing nation since its independence in 1947. Over the last 25 years, India has been noted for its significant economic growth, which looks to continue for the 2017 -2018 fiscal year with an expected growth rate of 7.2 percent. While India has maintained much financial success, many failures and weaknesses still debilitate the nation’s full potential. For example, the poverty rate in India has been less severe in recent years, but there is still much room for improvement.
According to the World Bank’s definition of extreme poverty in 2016, 270 million Indians made ends meet on $1.90 or less daily. Eighty percent of those affected by these circumstances resided in rural India, where everyday work is the primary source of income for the populace. Despite what would have appeared to be an economic boom over the previous 25 years, most growth has been in cities where the software development centers of huge international businesses like IBM and Microsoft are located. Economic growth does not appear to solve the problems of extreme poverty in the manner a neoliberal system would, given the gap between urban and rural living.
Even if educational advancements have not been exclusively responsible for India’s decline in extreme poverty over the past 20 years, the country’s poverty rate has been significantly impacted by investments made in improving the country’s primary education. Despite India’s low literacy and education rates compared to other countries, the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) has made significant strides recently and expanded its reach to all of India’s districts. According to a recent assessment, there is no teaching activity and low student progression rates in half of India’s government institutions. Promoting high-quality education is necessary if the country is to alleviate extreme poverty truly.
“Let people eat cake” says Pakistan Navy
In 1789 during yet another famine in France, the princess Marie Antoinette upon being told that the peasants had no bread, is said to have replied with frivolous disregard for the starving peasants with the words “Let them eat cake”. Today, the condition of the Pakistani citizens is quite similar to the French peasants of 1789.
The desperate economic conditions in Pakistan and the impact of floods has led the Finance Ministry to issue directives for implementing strict austerity measures for year 2022 – 2023. These measures aim to curtail operating expenditure and reduce the economic burden of the people.
However, it seems that these directives never reached their Navy.
Very recently, Pakistan Navy Ships Shamsheer and Nasr visited Yokosuka Port in Japan with an aim to participate in the International Fleet Review. In much contrast to the government verdict of “no unnecessary expenditure”, the visit was neither mandatory nor of importance. However much to the citizen’s dismay, neither the empty coffers nor the grave economic situation of the people seemed to deter the Navy from going on a tourism cum shopping spree.
Pakistan Navy Ships visit Yokosuka Port in Japan
In economically stable conditions, a Naval ship’s visit to a foreign port would have been welcomed by the citizens. However the economic burden posed by these activities have quadrupled the fear of a complete breakdown of society. While the cost of fuel for such a long voyage is in itself a huge deterrent, the fact that the ships will be stopping at almost five to seven countries during the futile passage, has made matters worse.
Monetary Implications of this cruise
Let’s look at the basic requirement of a naval voyage. The mandatory requirements include buying stores, fuel/lubricants, undertaking necessary repairs, paying the crew in international currency etc. But is this all? Definitely not. Each stop at a foreign port will require a mandatory interaction with the diplomats, exchange of gifts, parties with great pomp and show to announce the naval ships’ arrival, preparation of native cuisines etc.…The expenditure is definitely mind boggling.
Who is paying for this?
All this is paid through already depleting foreign reserves. Therefore understandably, if news of such frivolous expenditure, especially in these trying times were to reach the general public there would be a furore, and a well justified one. But Pakistan’s Navy has been clever, or at least it thinks it has been.
Where normally, all port visits are turned to a media circus by the Navy, this time not a single press release is available on the open media. Why? Because of a stringent gag order on issuing media bites by the government. The Navy has warned cruising ships to conduct events without the presence of press. The aim apparently is to prevent citizens from becoming aware of this trip to Japan. Pakistan’s naval commanders seem to be relying on their belief (definitely flawed and misguided) that – ordinary Pakistani citizen are like the proverbial ostrich with its head buried in the sand – what it cannot see, does not exist!
In today’s world where information travels faster than light – there are enough people who monitor everything. Which is why hiding the journey of two huge warships was definitely worthless. As soon as a local net-hawker identified the movement of the naval ships – the world and entire Pakistan was made aware of the secret journey. The Maverick could not outfox these people.
Frivolous Spending in Desperate Times
While one may still be able to find an excuse for Navy’s foreign visits, but what about the inflating expenditure on the procurement and projects, which are of no immediate importance? As pointed out by social media users a few days earlier, the Pakistan navy has been planning to procure four Frigates (each from Turkey and China), four to eight Corvettes (from the Netherlands), eight submarines (from China) and almost ten new aircraft for its maritime fleet.
Which brings a very interesting scenario to light – the huge lack of communication between the Pakistan’s government and its navy. On one hand the government has been insisting on cutting down operating costs and even travel/fuel usage by every ministry and service, but on the other, the Armed Forces are on a shopping spree. And whose money are these forces using? The question that the citizens of Pakistan need to ask is despite the mushrooming economic crisis, why is there a need to undertake such frivolous expenditure/cruises? And if they are really necessary, why the extra effort to hide it?
Many Pakistanis have already started asking such questions, a mass outcry is not far. And while the Pak armed forces especially its navy may pretend to be blissfully unaware of their countrymen’s plight, they must realize that secret voyages will not help the deplorable situation of their country and their fellow countrymen.
This article has been contributed by Commander Abhishek Rathi (Retd), Indian Naval Officer
Commander Abhishek Rathi (Retd) is a retired executive officer and holds an experience of commanding two naval warships. He has a keen interest in maritime history and technology. The officer is also an avid nature photographer and likes traveling all across India for it.
Leaked Audio Clip of Shehbaz Sharif – Pakistan PM Audio on Dark Web
If the PM’s house is not secure, how can the people of Pakistan rely on officials for their security? These statements were raised in local channels and TV debates in Pakistan, after the release of leaked audio clip of Shehbaz Sharif, Pakistan PM on the Dark Web. On 24th September 2022, several audio clips, allegedly recorded in the Prime Minister’s Office in Islamabad, were leaked online. “I will be releasing ALL files this Friday,” says a dark web message warning of more Pakistan audio leaks. The leaked audio is up for auction on Dark Web. Pakistan’s Intelligence sources have not said anything and are perplexed by this new development as they are yet to claim the credibility of the sources.
Nature of the Leaked Audio of Pakistan PM
The available audio on the dark Web contains interactions with journalists, government officers, premier military personnel also between the first family and extended families. A Twitter handle named Azhar Mashwani from Pakistan has tweeted some of the audio clips, one of which is related to the demand of Maryam Nawaz to Shehbaz Sharif to clear the way for her son-in-law`s machinery import from India. Also during the conversation, the PM house officials were heard saying to Shehbaz Sharif not to import plants from India as it will hurt the reputation of the government.
Refuting any illegal act in importing Power Plant from India, the Pakistan Information and Broadcasting Minister Marriyum Aurangzeb on Sunday said the audio leak has proved that neither an illegal act was committed nor any undue advantage was given to anyone.” There is a high court order on the installation of grid station on 18 July 2022,” further clarifying on the issue, she also mentioned that the power plant was under the policy formulated during the Imran Khan’s Tenure.
PTI leaders criticised the inefficient security agencies, Fawad Chaudhary claimed that the 100 hours long conversation is up for auction on the dark Web for around 28 crores ($3.5million). “Even the office of the prime minister of the nuclear-armed country is not safe”, Mr. Chaudhary told the media.
Also Read: Who Really Rules Pakistan?
Leaked Audio Clip of Shehbaz Sharif on Dark Web : Inside story
The leak has sparked a debate over the intentions of this incident, is it a conspiracy by someone to defame the ruling regime? To blackmail the government for certain decisions? or a cyber attack by someone in lust for some ransom.
One aspect of this can be traced by following the words of PTI leader Mirza Shehbaz Akbar who said that it is an insider’s job who wants to influence the decision-making before crucial appointments.” First it’s not a hack into the system (and) hacker (and) dark web seems like a cover story, our systems are based on analog and not digital that’s one way of Pak cyber security,” he said. He added that the timing of the leak was important “as it`s just before the crucial appointment, the target seems clear to influence the decision, which way though only time will tell!”.
Some have also targeted the country’s military for the leak, as they secretly record politicians’ conversations to blackmail them. Former Lawmaker Bushra Gohar who blamed the Pakistan Military for the leaked audio, told German news agency Deutsche Welle “It is a serious matter that even the PM’s office isn’t safe for any kind of security meeting. The audio contents are being discussed in public but no one is questioning the illegality of these recordings”.
The former PM Imran Khan used this opportunity to target the government, he said that the Sharif family went for the illegal occupation of a power plant from India, and wanted to make a good relationship with India ignoring the struggle of the Kashmiri people. He also highlighted that 60% of the federal cabinet is facing corruption charges and the main motive of Sharif’s family is to hoard money and nothing else.
One can’t deny the fact that there might be the possibility of involvement of PTI in this leak to push the government and security agencies on the back foot and to utilize it in gaining power in coming elections.
The leaked audio clip of Shehbaz Sharif on dark web is also raising questions from the PTI Chairman Imran Khan as in one of the Audio clips he is heard saying to his then former principal secretary, Azam Khan that “We only have to play on this. We don’t have to name [any country]. We only have to play with this, that this date was [decided] before,” reported Dawn. As Khan was ousted from the PM post, after which he leveled it as a foreign conspiracy. PM Sharif has said that Imran Khan only brought this ‘foreign conspiracy ‘ to evade his responsibilities and to stir up anti-American sentiments.
The possibilities are endless and time will tell what led to these audio leaks, which have raised pertinent questions on the integrity of the country’s highest office.
After the heated political atmosphere, Pakistan Cabinet has announced a high-level inquiry into the audio leaks. A debugging operation was also conducted at the PMO as well.
Technology9 months ago
Climate Crisis; Cries Asia
Archives1 year ago
Ramappa Temple: India’s 39th World Heritage Site
Defence5 months ago
The UAV Boom in India
Defence12 months ago
A cruel birth of Bangladesh by Archer K Blood: Book Review
Archives1 year ago
5 reasons why Bollywood has a monopoly over the Indian Music Industry
Polity2 years ago
Spotify announces the launch of HiFi audio streaming feature in India: Here’s all you need to know
Archives2 years ago
Anime and mental health
Technology2 years ago
Xiaomi now has a new logo that’s similar to its old logo